In the world of football, there are few positions as coveted and scrutinized as that of a quarterback. These players are the leaders of their team, responsible for making split-second decisions and leading their team to victory. Throughout the 21st century, there have been many talented quarterbacks who have graced the field, but only a select few have been able to make a lasting impact and solidify their place in history. Recently, a list was released ranking the top 25 quarterbacks of the 21st century, and to the surprise of many, two-time Super Bowl champion Eli Manning was not included. This snub has caused quite a stir among fans and analysts alike, especially considering that three other New York Giants quarterbacks made the list. Let’s take a closer look at this controversial ranking and the impact it has on Manning’s legacy.
The list, compiled by NFL Network’s “The Top 100 Players of 2021” show, was based on a panel of experts who evaluated the quarterbacks’ statistics, accolades, and impact on the game. Coming in at number 25 was former Giants quarterback Kerry Collins, who played for the team from 1999 to 2003. Collins was followed by current Giants quarterback Daniel Jones at number 22, and then by Phil Simms at number 21. While all three of these quarterbacks had successful careers with the Giants, it is surprising that Manning, who led the team to two Super Bowl victories, was not included.
Manning’s exclusion from the list has caused an uproar among fans and analysts, who argue that his accomplishments and impact on the game far outweigh those of the other Giants quarterbacks on the list. Manning, who played for the Giants from 2004 to 2019, holds numerous franchise records and is one of only five players in NFL history to win multiple Super Bowl MVP awards. He also holds the record for most consecutive starts by a quarterback, with an impressive 210 games played.
But it’s not just about the numbers for Manning. He was known for his clutch performances and ability to lead his team to victory in high-pressure situations. His iconic game-winning drive in Super Bowl XLII, where he evaded multiple defenders and connected with David Tyree for the famous “helmet catch,” will forever be etched in football history. And let’s not forget his game-winning drive in Super Bowl XLVI, where he once again led the Giants to victory over the New England Patriots.
Despite all of these accomplishments, Manning’s exclusion from the list has been attributed to his lack of consistency throughout his career. While he had some stellar seasons, he also had some subpar ones, leading to a lower overall ranking. But even with this inconsistency, Manning’s impact on the game cannot be denied. He was a leader both on and off the field, and his presence alone made the Giants a formidable opponent.
It’s also worth noting that the list only includes quarterbacks from the 21st century, meaning that legendary players like Tom Brady and Peyton Manning were not eligible. This makes Manning’s exclusion even more surprising, as he was able to achieve so much success in a highly competitive era of football.
But despite the disappointment of not making the list, Manning remains humble and gracious, as always. In a recent interview, he stated, “I don’t think I belong in that conversation. I know I’m not one of the top 25 quarterbacks in the 21st century. I’m okay with that.” This statement only further solidifies Manning’s character and selflessness, qualities that have made him a beloved figure in the football community.
In the end, while it may be disappointing to see Manning not included in this ranking, it does not take away from his incredible career and impact on the game. He will always be remembered as a two-time Super Bowl champion and a leader who brought the Giants to victory time and time again. And for Giants fans, that is all that truly matters.
In conclusion, while the recent ranking of the top 25 quarterbacks of the 21st century may have caused some controversy, it does not diminish the legacy of Eli Manning. He may not have made the list, but he will always be a top quarterback in the hearts of Giants fans and a respected figure in the football world. As Manning himself said, “I’m not trying to be the best quarterback in the league. I’m just trying to be the best quarterback for the Giants.” And for that